Advertising Disclosure Icing Comparison - September 2026
7 Best Icing In the UK
Our rankings are generated through the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. We use advanced technology, including AI, to help process and organize this information at scale, supporting our analysis with greater speed and consistency. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping.
Advertising Disclosure
| 1 Best Choice  9.8Exceptional | 2  9.5Excellent | 3  9.4Excellent | 4  9.3Excellent | 5  9.2Excellent | 6  9.0Excellent | 7  8.9Very Good |
| View DealOn Amazon | View DealOn Amazon | View DealOn Amazon | View DealOn Amazon | View DealOn Amazon | View DealOn Amazon | View DealOn Amazon |
ModelBetty Crocker Vanilla Buttercream Style Icing 400g (Pack of 6) | Model Renshaw White Ready to Roll Fondant Icing, 1 kg (Pack of 1) | Model Renshaw Natural Colours Fondant Icing Multipack, 5 x 100 g (Pack of 1) | Model Dr. Oetker Ready to Roll White Soft Fondant Icing, 1kg | Model Renshaw Primary Colours Fondant Icing Multipack, 5 x 100 g (Pack of 1) | Model Renshaw White Ready to Roll Fondant Icing, 250 g (Pack of 1) | Model Renshaw Dark Brown Ready to Roll Fondant Icing, 250 g (Pack of 1) |
BrandBetty Crocker | Brand Renshaw | Brand Renshaw | Brand Dr. Oetker | Brand Renshaw | Brand Renshaw | Brand Renshaw |
Reviews - | Reviews - | Reviews - | Reviews - | Reviews - | Reviews - | Reviews - |
Tech Specs | ||||||
age range description Adult | age range description Adult | age range description Adult | age range description Adult | age range description Adult | age range description ‎Adult | age range description ‎All Ages |
item form Creamy | item form Fondant Icing, Sugar Paste | item form Fondant Icing, Sugar Paste | item form Sheet | item form Paste | item form ‎Fondant Icing, Sugar Paste | item form ‎Fondant Icing, Sugar Paste |
size 400 g Pack of 6 | size 1 kg Pack of 1 | size 100 g Pack of 5 | size 1 kg Pack of 1 | size 100 g Pack of 5 | size ‎250 g (Pack of 1) | size ‎250 g (Pack of 1) |
unit count 2400.0 gram | unit count 1000.0 gram | unit count 500.0 gram | unit count 1000.0 gram | unit count 500.0 gram | unit count ‎1 Count | unit count ‎250.0 gram |
weight 2.4 kg | weight 1 kg | weight 0.53 Kilograms | weight 1 Kilograms | weight 0.5 Kilograms | weight ‎0.25 Kilograms | weight ‎250 g |
package information Packet, Tub | package information - | package information Pouch | package information Pouch | package information Bag | package information ‎Pouch | package information ‎Pouch |
manufacturer contact- | manufacturer contact JF Renshaw Ltd, 229 Crown St, Liverpool L8 7RF, United Kingdom | manufacturer contact JF Renshaw Ltd, 229 Crown St, Liverpool L8 7RF, United Kingdom | manufacturer contact Dr. Oetker UK Ltd., 4600 Park Approach, Thorpe Park, Leeds, LS15 8GB, UK. Dr. Oetker Ireland Ltd., Unit E13, Block E, Calmount Park, Ballymount, Dublin 12, Ireland. | manufacturer contact JF Renshaw Ltd, 229 Crown Street, Liverpool, Merseyside L8 7RF | manufacturer contact ‎British Bakels Limited, 229 Crown Street, Liverpool, Merseyside, L8 7RF | manufacturer contact ‎British Bakels Limited, 229 Crown Street, Liverpool, Merseyside, L8 7RF |
product dimensions- | product dimensions 5 x 12 x 19 cm 1 kg | product dimensions 4 x 12.5 x 13 cm 500 g | product dimensions 4.8 x 11.5 x 18.7 cm 1 g | product dimensions 4 x 12.5 x 13 cm 500 g | product dimensions ‎20 x 10.8 x 18 cm; 250 g | product dimensions ‎2 x 11 x 18 cm; 240 g |
global trade identification number 05010084902676 | global trade identification number - | global trade identification number 05010301360746 | global trade identification number - | global trade identification number 05010301360654 | global trade identification number ‎05010301326261 | global trade identification number ‎05010301329316 |
specialty suitable for vegetarians | specialty Suitable for Vegetarians, suitable for vegans | specialty Suitable for Vegans, Halal, Suitable for Vegetarians | specialty suitable for vegans | specialty suitable for vegetarians | specialty - | specialty - |
storage instructions- | storage instructions Store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate or freeze. Once opened, wrap in cling film, and place inside an air tight container to prevent drying out. | storage instructions Store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate or freeze. Once opened, wrap in cling film, and place inside an air tight container to prevent drying out. | storage instructions Store in a cool, dry place. Once opened, wrap any unused icing in polythene or foil to prevent it drying out. Do not refrigerate. Best before end see base of pack. | storage instructions - | storage instructions ‎Fondant Icing should be stored in dry conditions between 5°C and 18°C, away from heat sources and odourous materials. | storage instructions ‎Store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate or freeze. Once opened, wrap in cling film, and place inside an air tight container to prevent drying out. |
color- | color White | color Natural | color - | color Primary Colours | color ‎White | color ‎Dark Brown |
item weight 2.4 Kilograms | item weight - | item weight 500 Grams | item weight 1 Grams | item weight - | item weight ‎250 Grams | item weight - |
allergen information- | allergen information Contains: Tree nuts may contain | allergen information Contains: Crustacean Free, Fish Free, Sesame Seeds Free, Milk Free, Tree Nuts | allergen information - | allergen information - | allergen information ‎Contains: Crustacean Free, Fish Free, Milk Free, Sesame Seeds Free, Tree Nuts | allergen information ‎Contains: Tree nuts may contain |
serving recommendation- | serving recommendation Use at room temperature | serving recommendation Use at room temperature | serving recommendation - | serving recommendation - | serving recommendation ‎Use at room temperature | serving recommendation ‎Use at room temperature |
cuisine American | cuisine - | cuisine - | cuisine - | cuisine - | cuisine ‎Universal | cuisine ‎European |
carbohydrate- | carbohydrate - | carbohydrate 90 g | carbohydrate - | carbohydrate - | carbohydrate ‎90 g | carbohydrate ‎87 g |
energy kcal- | energy kcal - | energy kcal 396.74 kcal | energy kcal - | energy kcal - | energy kcal ‎393.39 kcal | energy kcal ‎412.28 kcal |
fat- | fat - | fat 3.9 g | fat - | fat - | fat ‎3.2 g | fat ‎6.7 g |
protein- | protein - | protein 0 g | protein - | protein - | protein ‎0 g | protein ‎0 g |
salt- | salt - | salt 0 g | salt - | salt - | salt ‎0 g | salt ‎0.03 g |
saturates- | saturates - | saturates 3.9 g | saturates - | saturates - | saturates ‎2 g | saturates ‎3.6 g |
serving size- | serving size - | serving size 100 g | serving size - | serving size - | serving size ‎100 g | serving size ‎100 g |
sugars- | sugars - | sugars 83 g | sugars - | sugars - | sugars ‎88.8 g | sugars ‎82 g |
Available On | Available On | Available On | Available On | Available On | Available On | Available On |
Our Top 3 Picks
Here are the top 3 recommended products with more information to help you find the right product for you
9.8
1Betty CrockerBetty Crocker Vanilla Buttercream Style Icing 400g (Pack of 6)
Main highlights- Suitable for vegetarians
- Smooth and full of flavour, this scrumptious vanilla buttercream icing is the ideal frosting for your Betty Crocker cakes and cupcakes
- Once opened seal and refrigerate any remaining icing for up to 30 days for future creations
- Gluten free
- Each tub contains enough icing to cover and fill an 8 Inch cake (serves 12) or cover up to 27 cupcakes
-
9.5
2Renshaw
Renshaw White Ready to Roll Fondant Icing, 1 kg (Pack of 1)
Why we love it
Easier kneading and improved vanilla flavor.
Available in over 20 vibrant and pastel colors.
Pliable, strong, and versatile for shaping anything.
Main highlights- VERSATILE - Fondant icing includes tragacanth making it pliable and strong so it can be worked and shaped into just about anything
- NEW AND IMPROVED - You talked we listened, now easier to knead, has improved vanilla flavour and better functionality. Suitable for vegetarian and vegans
- LARGE RANGE OF COLOURS - Available in over 20 colours from soft pastels to vibrant shades
- HOW MUCH DO I NEED? - For a 5" tall cake rolling to 2mm thick: for a cake 4" width: 250 g, 6" width: 400 g, 8" width: 500 g, 10" width: 750 g and a 12" width: 1 kg
- BAKING FOR EVERYONE - Renshaw want to be part of your baking experience whether you are a complete novice or a professional. We celebrate imperfectly perfect!
-
9.4
3Renshaw
Renshaw Natural Colours Fondant Icing Multipack, 5 x 100 g (Pack of 1)
Why we love it
Easier to knead and shape.
Enhanced vanilla flavor.
Vegan-friendly and versatile.
Main highlights- VERSATILE - Fondant icing includes gum tragacanth; making it pliable and strong; so it can be worked and shaped into just about anything; Create model flowers, people, and animals; Works well with cutters and in moulds for embellishments & decorations
- TAKE YOUR PICK - Natural Multipack features: black, white, peach blush, teddy bear brown and chocolate flavour fondant icing
- PERFECT BLANK CANVAS FOR CREATIVITY - For any cake, cupcake or bake; It can be rolled out; hand modelled or used with cutters and moulds; ideal for decorating cakes, cupcakes and cookies
- NEW AND IMPROVED - You talked we listened, now easier to knead, has improved vanilla flavour and better functionality. Suitable for vegetarian and vegans
- BAKING FOR EVERYONE - Renshaw want to be part of your baking experience whether you are a complete novice or a professional. We celebrate imperfectly perfect!
Our ranking system
The topchoice.co.uk Team selects top-of-the-line items from a wide selection and conducts rigorous evaluations on almost all the products available on the internet. We rank each product based on how well it matches our criteria.We can ensure that the product is well-tested with the help of our expertise, experts, and artificial intelligence technology. topchoice.co.uk requires consistent care for the products we review, ensuring that our assessments are always accurate and up to date.
Features
Our team of experts analyzes key attributes, capabilities, significance, and many more depending on the type of product to determine its effectiveness.
Consumer Reviews
We ensure an evaluation of the ratings using references all over the internet for each product. With the help of our AI technology and professional review teams, we give weight to the worth of individual user experiences.
Popularity
Popularity is an important criterion in choosing a product. Several factors contribute to the popularity of the products on our site, including prestige, relevance, reputation, news, and more.
Value for money
topchoice.co.uk compares product attributes to price, examines tech specs, ratings and reviews, and more.When compared to other criteria, does the pricing seem reasonable? In order to provide genuine value for money, our team must answer that question with advanced calculations.
Value for money
topchoice.co.uk compares product attributes to price, examines tech specs, ratings and reviews, and more.When compared to other criteria, does the pricing seem reasonable? In order to provide genuine value for money, our team must answer that question with advanced calculations.
